Strategos Books & Videos

The Strategos Guide To Value Stream & Process Mapping Guide To Cycle Counting & Inventory Accuracy

Facilities Planning & Workplace Design Warehouse Modernization & Planning Guide The Human Side of Lean Video

eBooks On Sale!

Leadership Levels and Issues

Leadership Levels

Leadership for Lean Manufacturing

Lean Resources

Home
Resources
Site Guide
Lean Training
Book Reviews
Search Site
Useful Links
About Strategos
Contact

 

Downloads

 

Charismatic  Self-Assessment

 

Leadership Lessons From Twelve O'clock High

 

Seminars

 

Team Leadership

 

Planning, Leading & Managing The Lean Manufacturing Journey

 

Printer-Friendly PDF of Leadership Series

What Is Leadership?

Leadership is about influencing others to  take actions and adopt behaviors that accomplish a goal or a mission.

This is a complex topic. It may be viewed from many perspectives. In this series of articles, we give a view of leadership synthesized from several established perspectives.

Issues and Problems

For most organizations, problems prevent the direct, linear achievement of a goal. The tasks for accomplishment may be murky and solutions to problems may be unclear.  Moreover, the goal itself may be unclear, unknown or controversial.

The problems faced by an organization may be adaptive in nature. Adaptive problems require changes in organizations structure, behavior, values, culture or objectives. Non-adaptive problems simply require the application of existing approaches.

The people who should be involved in problem-solving varies. It depends on the problem and the available solutions.

Table 1 summarizes several types of problem-solution complexes and the people that should be involved in their resolution. These various problem-solution combinations require different levels of leadership.

Table 1-- Organizational Issues

Problem/Issue Types Solutions Available People Involved

Adaptive, Non-Technical & Unclear

Unknown and Unclear; Requires Evolution of Values and Innovation

All Stakeholders

Non-Technical but Clear

Partly Known -Some Adaptive Learning Required

Experts Aid Diagnosis; Group Solves Problem

Technical & Clear

Technical, Solutions Exist

Expert-Leader Solves Problem

 

Levels of Leadership

Table 2 summarizes one perspective on leadership. It views leadership at different levels: Transactional, Relational, Transformational and Charismatic. Clicking on each the level takes you to a further discussion of that leadership level.

If we map the leadership levels of table 2 to the issue types of table 1, we see that lower levels of leadership can cope with technical and non-adaptive problems.  Murky, adaptive issues require higher levels of leadership.

Different writers and researchers attach different meaning to these terms. For example, some writers view charismatic leaders as any leader possessing charisma and include people such as David Koresh and Jim Jones in this category.

Others view charismatic leaders as transformational leaders with the added characteristic of charisma. When viewing these pages and the other literature, you must infer from the context whether the discussion is about the pure Charismatic or Transformational- Charismatic Leader.

 

Table 2-- Levels of Leadership

  Level Activities & Competencies Personal Characteristics
IV

Charismatic- Transformational

(Click for More Detail)

  • All of Level III +...

  • Personal Charisma

  • All of Level III +...

  • Self-Confident

  • Knows Him/Herself

  • Eloquent

  • Free of Internal Conflict

  • Expressive  Emotionally

III

Transformational

(Click for More Detail)

  • All of Level II +...

  • Frames Holistic Issues

  • Sets New Goals & Direction

  • Creates Meaning

  • Manages Creative Conflict

  • Promotes Organizational Learning

  • Creates A Context for Dialogue

  • Manages Paradigms

  • Creates Commitment Through Shared Values

  • Assertive

  • Seizes Opportunities

  • Tolerates Risk

  • Uses Systems Thinking

II

Relational

(Click for More Detail)

  • Creates Commitment Through Participation

  • Motivates Intrinsically

  • Promotes Teamwork

  • Manages Politics

  • Works Within  Existing System

  • Participative & Consultative

I

Transactional

(Click for More Detail)

  • Accepts Organizational Goals

  • Uses  Extrinsic Motivators

  • Works Within  Existing System

  • Takes Action

  • Directive

  • Dominating

  • Action-Oriented

China

Lean Manufacturing Academy

Europe

Jung, Aust & Partner

Australia

Peter J. Ellis

North America

Sims Consulting Group

Strategic Impact

 

 

 

Japan Study Mission

Subscribe to Lean Briefing-- The Free Newsletter of Lean Manufacturing Strategy

    Enter Anti-Spam Code--->

 

Lean Briefing is sent about every month. You may "unsubscribe" at any time.

We will NOT: Sell this information, transfer it, bombard you with Email, or otherwise abuse your trust

 

Strategos-International:  China - Europe - Australia - North America